Affiliate Disclosure: As an eBay Partner Network Affiliate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Treblemakers may also earn commissions from Reverb and other marketplace links. This doesn't affect the price you pay. Learn more
Used pedals are among the safest used music gear to buy — most are simple, robust circuits. Here's what to test, which brands are most reliable, and 8 pedals worth buying used.
Updated
Analog pedals (overdrive, fuzz, boost) are the easiest used gear to evaluate — the circuits have barely changed since the 1960s and failures are uncommon. Digital pedals (delay, reverb) are more complex but brands like Boss and Strymon build to high standards.
All prices below are current used market values (mid-2026). Most pedal failures are cheap fixes — crackling pots, dirty jacks, and dead batteries are all negotiating points, not dealbreakers.
Best for: Players who want a reliable, inexpensive distortion foundation
The most ubiquitous pedal ever made — indestructible build, dead simple one-knob interface. Any working DS-1 is a good buy at $35–$45. Vintage Japan-made versions (look for 'Made in Japan' on the PCB) have a slightly warmer character.
What to check used: Check the LED and bypass function. Cheap input/output jacks are the most common failure point.
Best for: Blues and classic rock players wanting amp-friendly mid-hump overdrive
The best-selling overdrive of all time. The TS9 is the modern equivalent; the TS808 is the original. Both have the characteristic mid-hump that makes them work perfectly in front of an already-breaking-up amp. Reissue TS808s from 1996+ are genuine Ibanez Japan production. TS9: $60–$120 used; TS808: $120–$200 used.
What to check used: Crackling pots (clean with DeoxIT), and verify the JRC4558D chip is present in vintage units — a key part of the TS808 tone.
Best for: Players wanting a simple, reliable first delay pedal
Boss digital delays are nearly indestructible and straightforward. The DD-3 is the simpler option; DD-7 adds modulation modes. Either is an excellent first delay pedal. DD-3T: $60–$100 used; DD-7: $80–$120 used.
What to check used: Test all modes and delay time settings. Digital delay chips rarely fail — verify the tone control works and all modes engage.
Best for: Funk and classic rock players wanting vintage phaser character
The classic EHX phaser — used on countless records. The 'Color' switch adds presence. EHX quality is adequate but not Boss-tier, so inspect carefully.
What to check used: Battery contacts corrode easily on older EHX pedals. Test with a power supply, not a battery, to isolate power source issues.
Best for: Classic rock and blues players wanting one-knob phaser — Eddie Van Halen's choice
Eddie Van Halen's phaser — the simplest, most musical phaser circuit. One knob, two types (script vs block logo). The script logo ('Script Phase 90') has a softer, more vintage character; block logo has more intensity.
What to check used: Script logo versions are worth slightly more. MXR quality is very high — failures are uncommon, so any issues usually indicate prior damage.
Best for: Players wanting versatile reverb in a standard Boss enclosure
Eight reverb types in a standard Boss enclosure. The shimmer and modulated reverb modes are particularly useful. Boss reliability means finding a working unit is almost guaranteed.
What to check used: Test the 'dynamic' mode which responds to picking dynamics — it should open and close naturally without any crackling.
Best for: Serious players and producers wanting studio-quality reverb
The premium reverb option. Strymon pedals hold value extremely well — a used BigSky at $250 is a great deal for studio-quality reverb. Build quality is exceptional. BigSky: $200–$280 used; BlueSky: $120–$160 used.
What to check used: Verify software version and test all 12 reverb types. Strymon pedals rarely fail — but their value means verifying everything before you commit.
Best for: Hendrix fans and classic rock/punk players wanting vintage fuzz
The classic Hendrix fuzz. Original Dallas Arbiter and Dunlop reissues are the market standard. Silicon fuzz (BC108 transistor) is more consistent; germanium fuzz (AC128) is temperature-sensitive but beloved. Clones: $40–$80 used; vintage style: $80–$150 used.
What to check used: Germanium transistors are sensitive to heat — test in a warm room if buying germanium. Silicon is more reliable and consistent.
Generally yes — most guitar pedals use simple, robust circuitry. Analog overdrive, fuzz, and boost pedals are especially durable — the circuits date back to the 1960s. Digital pedals (digital delay, reverb, modulation) are more complex but brands like Boss, Strymon, and TC Electronic build to high standards. The main risk is environmental damage (water, heat, physical impacts) and pot wear — both are obvious on inspection.
Strymon pedals (BigSky, Mobius, Timeline) hold 70–80% of retail value and are frequently resold near new prices. Vintage and discontinued analog pedals (original Ibanez TS808 with JRC4558D chip, vintage MXR Phase 90 with script logo, Dallas Arbiter Fuzz Face) appreciate over time. Boss DS-1 and DD-series pedals hold around 50–60% of retail.
Avoid pedals with: cracked PCB traces (visible inside, results in intermittent output), water damage (look for corrosion on pots and jacks), replaced bypass switches (often indicate repeated bypass failures), and SMD-board digital pedals with no output (expensive to repair). Crackling pots, dirty jacks, and dead batteries are all fine — they're cheap, easy fixes.
True bypass means when the pedal is off, the signal passes directly from input to output with no buffering or coloration. True bypass pedals (most boutique and modern Boss) are simpler circuits — the bypass switch is the only failure point. Buffered bypass (most older Boss) adds a buffer IC that can occasionally fail but preserves signal integrity in longer chains.
Reverb is the standard — the largest selection of used pedals, with reasonable buyer protections and a community that mostly prices accurately. Local guitar shops have smaller selections but you can test before buying. Facebook Marketplace is cheapest but has no buyer protections. eBay works well for vintage pedals where you need buyer protection for authenticity disputes.
Get weekly used gear deals in your inbox
Price drops, new listings, and buyer tips — free, every week.
Unsubscribe any time.
Professional Appraisal
Generate an CMA appraisal report in minutes. We pull comparable sold listings from Reverb, eBay, Guitar Center, and more — you select the comps, get statistical analysis, and download a professional PDF. Starting at $8.99.