How to Buy a Used Guitar 2026

Affiliate Disclosure: As an eBay Partner Network Affiliate, we earn from qualifying purchases. Treblemakers may also earn commissions from Reverb and other marketplace links. This doesn't affect the price you pay. Learn more

Time:1–3 hours

Budget:$100–$5,000

Buying a used guitar is one of the smartest moves in music. You get far more instrument for your money than buying new — a $600 used guitar almost always beats a $600 new guitar because the first owner absorbed the depreciation. The catch is that condition varies wildly, and inexperienced buyers get burned by cracks, bad necks, and misrepresented "vintage" guitars.

This guide covers every step from search to arrival. Follow it once and you'll know exactly what to look for — on the listing photos, in the seller's description, and when the guitar lands at your door.

What You'll Need

A budget in mind
Access to Reverb, eBay, or Treblemakers
A flashlight (for in-person inspections)
A tuner (free smartphone app works)

Step-by-Step Guide (10 Steps)

Set a Realistic Budget
Decide your hard ceiling before you start browsing. Used guitar prices are emotion-driven — it's easy to convince yourself that "just $100 more" is worth it mid-search. Know your max before you open any listing. A practical breakdown: under $300 is beginner territory (Squier, Yamaha Pacifica, Epiphone); $300–$800 covers excellent mid-range instruments (Fender Player, PRS SE, Taylor Academy); $800–$2,000 gets you pro-grade used gear (Fender American, Gibson ES-335, Martin 000-15M). Factor in setup costs — most used guitars need a $50–$100 professional setup before they play their best.
Add 10% to your listed budget as a "setup buffer." A guitar priced at $450 that needs a $60 setup is a $510 guitar.
Decide on Guitar Type
Acoustic vs. electric vs. bass vs. acoustic-electric — get this right before browsing or you'll waste hours. Acoustic guitars are self-contained and great for singer-songwriters; they need no gear other than a tuner. Electric guitars require an amp, cable, and picks at minimum, adding $100–$400 to your startup cost. Bass guitars are for low-end roles in bands. Acoustic-electric guitars bridge both worlds but tend to sound mediocre plugged in unless you spend more. If you're undecided, an acoustic is the lowest total-cost-of-ownership starting point.
Used acoustic guitars under $300 are often genuinely excellent — brands like Yamaha, Seagull, and Fender produce high-quality laminate-top instruments that hold up well on the used market.
Research Specific Models Before Browsing
Never search for "guitar" — search for a specific model you've already researched. Read reviews on Guitar World, Sweetwater, and YouTube. Identify 3–5 models that fit your type and budget. This keeps you anchored when sellers try to upsell, and helps you spot when something is overpriced. Good research targets: find the current Reverb "sold" average for each model (not the asking price — the sold price). Treblemakers' valuation pages pull 90-day sold comp data, which is the most accurate benchmark available.
The Reverb Price Guide and Treblemakers' valuation pages both pull from actual sold listings — use either to know the real market rate before negotiating.
Search Multiple Marketplaces
Don't limit yourself to one platform. Reverb is the largest dedicated used music gear marketplace — best selection, most seller transparency. eBay has the broadest reach and competitive pricing, especially for vintage instruments. Guitar Center's used inventory is available online and in-store — condition grades are conservative, which makes them reliable. Craigslist and Facebook Marketplace offer local deals but zero buyer protection. Treblemakers aggregates Reverb, eBay, and Guitar Center into one search, which saves significant time when comparing across platforms.
Sort by "recently listed" rather than "best match" on each platform — new listings move fast and the best deals often appear and disappear within 24–48 hours.
Scrutinize Every Listing Photo
Good sellers photograph all six sides of the guitar body, both sides of the headstock, the full neck length, the fretboard close-up, all tuning machines, the nut, the bridge, and any damage. Red flags: only 1–3 photos, no photos of the back, no close-up of the headstock. If photos are missing, ask for them before proceeding. Specific things to examine: cracks or buckle rash on the body finish, fret wear on frets 1–5 (the most commonly used), finish checking (fine cracks in the lacquer — normal on vintage, concerning on newer guitars), headstock cracks (extremely expensive to repair), and bridge lifting on acoustics.
A crack near the heel joint (where the neck meets the body) on an acoustic guitar is a structural issue that can cost more than the guitar to repair. If you see any crack in that area, ask for a luthier assessment first.
Check the Neck and Action
The neck is the most important structural component. Sight down the neck from the headstock: it should be laser-straight with a barely perceptible forward bow (relief). A back-bow or severe S-curve is serious. "Action" is the string height above the frets — it affects playability more than almost anything else. Low action means easy playing; high action causes hand fatigue and intonation issues. Ask sellers: "What is the action at the 12th fret, high and low E strings?" Acceptable answers for electric: 4/64" (low E) and 3/64" (high E). For acoustic: 7/64" (low E) and 5/64" (high E). High action can often be fixed with a setup, but neck issues may not be fixable.
A guitar with slightly high action sold as-is is often a hidden deal — it just needs a $50–$75 setup at a guitar tech to play great.
Research the Seller's Reputation
On Reverb, check the seller's feedback count and percentage — only consider sellers with 95%+ positive feedback or at least 20 completed transactions. Read the negative reviews specifically; they often reveal patterns (poor packing, inaccurate descriptions). On eBay, same principle — check detailed seller ratings for "Item as described." For Guitar Center used, condition grades are standardized across stores (Excellent, Good, Fair) so individual seller trust is less of a factor. For Facebook Marketplace and Craigslist, meet in a public place or, if mailing, use a payment method with buyer protection (PayPal G&S, not F&F).
Never pay via wire transfer, Zelle, Venmo (for business transactions), or Western Union for a guitar purchase from a stranger. These have no buyer protection and scammers frequently target Craigslist music gear listings.
Ask the Right Questions
Message sellers with specific questions before purchasing: Has the guitar had any repairs? Are there any cracks, even repaired ones? Is the neck straight? What is the action at the 12th fret? Does it have the original case/gig bag? Legitimate sellers answer detailed questions confidently — they know their gear. Vague answers, deflection ("it plays fine"), or pressure to buy quickly are red flags. Also ask: "Would you accept $X?" — most sellers price with negotiation room built in.
A seller who mentions a specific luthier name, describes a repair in detail, or provides photos of the interior of an acoustic (via phone torch) is demonstrating they know the instrument — a good sign.
Make a Fair Offer
Use the sold comp data from step 3 to anchor your offer. A reasonable opening offer is 10–15% below asking on Reverb/eBay, or 5–10% below on Guitar Center used (less markup room). State your reason briefly: "Based on similar sold listings I've seen at $X, would you take $Y?" Never lowball by more than 20% — it's insulting and usually kills the deal. Counter-offers are normal. If a seller won't budge at all, either the price is genuinely fair or they're not motivated — move on rather than overpaying.
The best time to get a deal on Reverb is when a listing has been active for 30+ days. Sellers are usually more flexible after the initial listing excitement fades.
Inspect Thoroughly on Arrival
When your guitar arrives, inspect it before touching the strings. Check every surface against the listing photos. Tune it up slowly and let it acclimate to room temperature for 30 minutes if it's been in a cold truck. Play every fret on every string listening for buzzing — some buzz is normal; buzz on the open strings or at every fret suggests a neck issue. Check tuning stability by playing for 10 minutes. Test the electronics if it's an electric. Most online platforms offer a return window (Reverb: 7 days, eBay: 30 days for most sellers) — use it if the guitar doesn't match the description.
Photograph the guitar within 10 minutes of opening the box. If you need to file a return claim, timestamped unboxing photos are your best evidence.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it safe to buy a used guitar online without playing it first?

Yes, with the right precautions. Reverb and eBay both offer buyer protection — if the guitar doesn't match the listing description, you can return it. Stick to sellers with 95%+ feedback, ask detailed questions, and request additional photos. The used guitar market online is generally safe for buyers who do their homework.

What is a fair price for a used guitar?

Used guitars typically sell for 40–70% of their original retail price depending on condition, age, and demand. Check Reverb's "sold" listings (not asking prices) for the most accurate data — or use Treblemakers' valuation pages which pull 90-day sold comp medians.

Should I buy used from Guitar Center or Reverb?

Both are legitimate, with different trade-offs. Guitar Center used inventory has standardized condition grades and an in-store return option. Reverb has more selection and competitive pricing, but quality varies more between sellers. If you're inexperienced, Guitar Center's "Excellent" grade is a reliable starting point. If you want the best deals and can evaluate photos, Reverb wins on price.

What should I always check on a used acoustic guitar?

Five things: (1) the top for cracks, especially near the soundhole and along the seams; (2) the bridge for lifting; (3) the neck for straightness and fret wear; (4) the headstock for cracks (expensive to repair); and (5) the inside via the soundhole for any signs of previous repair. A cracked top or bridge lift on an acoustic is a significant structural concern.

Is it worth paying for a professional setup on a used guitar?

Almost always yes. A setup ($50–$100) adjusts the neck relief, action, nut slots, and intonation to optimal specs for your playing. Most used guitars haven't been set up in years. A well-setup guitar plays easier, stays in tune better, and sounds better — it's one of the best investments you can make in any guitar.

Get weekly used guitars deals in your inbox

Price drops, new listings, and buyer tips — free, every week.

Unsubscribe any time.